Straight guy thought he was getting head from a girl but he was wrong

A Hung Straight Boy goes Over a Man's Knee for a Spanking

Matt's ass clinched tight as I pushed thru his ring-of-fire

Tariq's thick cock pulsed throughout the anal play with him on the edge of orgasm the entire time.

A foda mais romântica e linda que já vi na vida

Braydyn's been working out, has let his hair grow out, & he's even more beautiful today than he was six years ago - if that's even possible. When I saw him flash his pearly whites, all I could do was GRRRWOOF and say, "Let's g

Enjoy Gunner's return with a special appearance by the original Zaddy, Ken Mack!

Xen has two TELLS, his throbbing cock & his pulsing pussy

Ewan’s entire body was on sensory overload. It was one of the most erotic things to witness and actually participate in!

Next in the CAUSA Classic CUMpilation series, I decided to jump forward to 2008 when 19-year-old, active-duty AF Morgan slid onto the ClubAmateurUSA massage table.

Straight hunk gets rimmed and fucked for money

I knew when Shayne contacted me on my favorite sex and swingers site, that I was hell bent to capture him on video. He's young, hung, hella cute, and sexually curious. Uhm... PERFECT!

Eat straight guy ass and cum

In this new vid with Soren, he has two orgasms and cumshots within 20 minutes of each other. But Soren made me work it for it!

To celebrate ClubAmateurUSA's 750th exclusive, original video and also exclusive to CAUSA, the Emperor Gracen returns!

Going all the way back to October 2003 and the ClubAmateurUSA for this week's CAUSA Classic CUMpilation, we have our original Silver Daddy, Matt!

He's BAAAAaaaack! For the first time since December 2019, CAUSA's Elias returns to the table!

Having seen Tulio's junk in the pix on his Reddit profile, I was rather impressed. I'm even more impressed having now seen it in person.

straight guy gets fucked in ass by 2 friends

Comendo o Branquelo do Rabão enchi o rabo dele de Pica e Leite

Handsome, hot, hung, and hairy - Enrique checked all the boxes to be a CAUSA guy!

I got out the studded manrammer & Devlin took it like a champ

Fingering massage

Real str8 insurrer gets fingered in spite of himself by us during a massage.

This handsome massage boy rimmed my ass

20091129 kylestevens perf

Two arabs fucking a white twink

Salesman in suit trousers gets wanked his huge cock by a guy !

AsianMan & WhiteMan

BBC muscle bottom

Horny naked jock gets a naughty massage

True str8 male gets ass massaged by guys ! Vlad.

Hombre disfrutando

Muscle Leather Cop